Journal Article
. 2012 Mar; 106(6):1053-61.
doi: 10.1038/bjc.2012.61.

Making hard choices easier: a prospective, multicentre study to assess the efficacy of a fertility-related decision aid in young women with early-stage breast cancer

M Peate 1 B Meiser  B C Cheah  C Saunders  P Butow  B Thewes  R Hart  K-A Phillips  M Hickey  M Friedlander  
  • PMID: 22415294
  •     41 References
  •     46 citations


Background: Fertility is a priority for many young women with breast cancer. Women need to be informed about interventions to retain fertility before chemotherapy so as to make good quality decisions. This study aimed to prospectively evaluate the efficacy of a fertility-related decision aid (DA).

Methods: A total of 120 newly diagnosed early-stage breast cancer patients from 19 Australian oncology clinics, aged 18-40 years and desired future fertility, were assessed on decisional conflict, knowledge, decision regret, and satisfaction about fertility-related treatment decisions. These were measured at baseline, 1 and 12 months, and were examined using linear mixed effects models.

Results: Compared with usual care, women who received the DA had reduced decisional conflict (β=-1.51; 95%CI: -2.54 to 0.48; P=0.004) and improved knowledge (β=0.09; 95%CI: 0.01-0.16; P=0.02), after adjusting for education, desire for children and baseline uncertainty. The DA was associated with reduced decisional regret at 1 year (β=-3.73; 95%CI: -7.12 to -0.35; P=0.031), after adjusting for education. Women who received the DA were more satisfied with the information received on the impact of cancer treatment on fertility (P<0.001), fertility options (P=0.005), and rated it more helpful (P=0.002), than those who received standard care.

Conclusion: These findings support widespread use of this DA shortly after diagnosis (before chemotherapy) among younger breast cancer patients who have not completed their families.

Chemoprevention of breast cancer with selective estrogen receptor modulators: views from broadly diverse focus groups of women with elevated risk for breast cancer.
M S Cyrus-David, S S Strom.
Psychooncology, 2001 Dec 18; 10(6). PMID: 11747064
The menopausal symptom experience in young mid-life women with breast cancer.
M T Knobf.
Cancer Nurs, 2001 Jun 21; 24(3). PMID: 11409064
Chemotherapy-induced amenorrhea and fertility in women undergoing adjuvant treatment for breast cancer.
Susan E Minton, Pamela N Munster.
Cancer Control, 2003 Jan 07; 9(6). PMID: 12514564
Importance of faith on medical decisions regarding cancer care.
Gerard A Silvestri, Sommer Knittig, James S Zoller, Paul J Nietert.
J Clin Oncol, 2003 Mar 29; 21(7). PMID: 12663730
Menopause after breast cancer: a survey on breast cancer survivors.
Nicoletta Biglia, Marilena Cozzarella, +4 authors, Piero Sismondi.
Maturitas, 2003 May 20; 45(1). PMID: 12753941
The fertility- and menopause-related information needs of younger women with a diagnosis of breast cancer: a qualitative study.
Belinda Thewes, Bettina Meiser, Judy Rickard, Michael Friedlander.
Psychooncology, 2003 Jul 02; 12(5). PMID: 12833562
Validation of a decision regret scale.
Jamie C Brehaut, Annette M O'Connor, +4 authors, Deb Feldman-Stewart.
Med Decis Making, 2003 Aug 21; 23(4). PMID: 12926578
Highly Cited.
The psychosocial needs of breast cancer survivors; a qualitative study of the shared and unique needs of younger versus older survivors.
B Thewes, P Butow, A Girgis, S Pendlebury.
Psychooncology, 2004 Mar 17; 13(3). PMID: 15022153
Web-based survey of fertility issues in young women with breast cancer.
Ann H Partridge, Shari Gelber, +7 authors, Eric P Winer.
J Clin Oncol, 2004 Oct 16; 22(20). PMID: 15483028
Highly Cited.
Emergency decision making: a theoretical analysis of responses to disaster warnings.
I L Janis, L Mann.
J Human Stress, 1977 Jun 01; 3(2). PMID: 864252
The hospital anxiety and depression scale.
A S Zigmond, R P Snaith.
Acta Psychiatr Scand, 1983 Jun 01; 67(6). PMID: 6880820
Highly Cited.
Screening for anxiety and depression in cancer patients: the effects of disease and treatment.
T Ibbotson, P Maguire, +2 authors, L Wallace.
Eur J Cancer, 1994 Jan 01; 30A(1). PMID: 8142161
Validation of a decisional conflict scale.
A M O'Connor.
Med Decis Making, 1995 Jan 01; 15(1). PMID: 7898294
Highly Cited.
Ovarian function in premenopausal women treated with adjuvant chemotherapy for breast cancer.
J Bines, D M Oleske, M A Cobleigh.
J Clin Oncol, 1996 May 01; 14(5). PMID: 8622093
Highly Cited. Review.
Psychology of computer use: XL. Addictive use of the Internet: a case that breaks the stereotype.
K S Young.
Psychol Rep, 1996 Dec 01; 79(3 Pt 1). PMID: 8969098
Highly Cited.
Randomized trial of a portable, self-administered decision aid for postmenopausal women considering long-term preventive hormone therapy.
A M O'Connor, P Tugwell, +7 authors, T Mackenzie.
Med Decis Making, 1998 Jul 29; 18(3). PMID: 9679994
Decision-making about tamoxifen in women at high risk for breast cancer: clinical and psychological factors.
Sharon L Bober, Lizbeth A Hoke, +2 authors, Nadine M Tung.
J Clin Oncol, 2004 Dec 16; 22(24). PMID: 15598980
Discussions regarding reproductive health for young women with breast cancer undergoing chemotherapy.
Christine M Duffy, Susan M Allen, Melissa A Clark.
J Clin Oncol, 2005 Feb 01; 23(4). PMID: 15681520
Fertility preservation in breast cancer patients: a prospective controlled comparison of ovarian stimulation with tamoxifen and letrozole for embryo cryopreservation.
Kutluk Oktay, Erkan Buyuk, +2 authors, Zev Rosenwaks.
J Clin Oncol, 2005 Apr 13; 23(19). PMID: 15824416
Surgeon's recommendation, perceived operative efficacy and age dictate treatment choice by Chinese women facing breast cancer surgery.
Wendy W T Lam, Richard Fielding, +2 authors, Amy Or.
Psychooncology, 2004 Nov 17; 14(7). PMID: 15546161
Fertility- and menopause-related information needs of younger women with a diagnosis of early breast cancer.
B Thewes, B Meiser, +7 authors, M L Friedlander.
J Clin Oncol, 2005 Jul 30; 23(22). PMID: 16051957
American Society of Clinical Oncology recommendations on fertility preservation in cancer patients.
Stephanie J Lee, Leslie R Schover, +7 authors, American Society of Clinical Oncology.
J Clin Oncol, 2006 May 03; 24(18). PMID: 16651642
Highly Cited. Systematic Review.
Religion, infertility and assisted reproductive technology.
Andrew Dutney.
Best Pract Res Clin Obstet Gynaecol, 2006 Nov 18; 21(1). PMID: 17110170
Recent increase of breast cancer incidence among women under the age of forty.
C Bouchardy, G Fioretta, +10 authors, E Rapiti.
Br J Cancer, 2007 May 30; 96(11). PMID: 17533391    Free PMC article.
Interpreting clinically significant changes in patient-reported outcomes.
Jolie Ringash, Brian O'Sullivan, Andrea Bezjak, Donald A Redelmeier.
Cancer, 2007 Jun 05; 110(1). PMID: 17546575
Age of menopause among women who remain premenopausal following treatment for early breast cancer: long-term results from International Breast Cancer Study Group Trials V and VI.
Ann Partridge, Shari Gelber, +3 authors, Eric Winer.
Eur J Cancer, 2007 May 22; 43(11). PMID: 17512721
Low uptake of colorectal cancer screening 3 yr after release of national recommendations for screening.
S Elizabeth McGregor, Robert J Hilsden, +2 authors, Alison Murray.
Am J Gastroenterol, 2007 Apr 18; 102(8). PMID: 17437502
Patient-physician communication barriers regarding fertility preservation among newly diagnosed cancer patients.
Gwendolyn P Quinn, Susan T Vadaparampil, +2 authors, Terrance L Albrecht.
Soc Sci Med, 2007 Nov 21; 66(3). PMID: 18023955
Discussion of fertility preservation with newly diagnosed patients: oncologists' views.
Gwendolyn P Quinn, Susan T Vadaparampil, +5 authors, Pamela Munster.
J Cancer Surviv, 2008 Jul 24; 1(2). PMID: 18648955
The fertility-related concerns, needs and preferences of younger women with breast cancer: a systematic review.
Michelle Peate, Bettina Meiser, Martha Hickey, Michael Friedlander.
Breast Cancer Res Treat, 2009 Apr 25; 116(2). PMID: 19390962
Systematic Review.
Decision aids for people facing health treatment or screening decisions.
Annette M O'Connor, Carol L Bennett, +9 authors, David Rovner.
Cochrane Database Syst Rev, 2009 Jul 10; (3). PMID: 19588325
Highly Cited. Systematic Review.
Breast cancer survivors and fertility preservation: ethical and religious considerations.
Angela Jukkala.
Semin Oncol Nurs, 2009 Nov 03; 25(4). PMID: 19879434
Economics of assisted reproductive technologies.
Baris Ata, Emre Seli.
Curr Opin Obstet Gynecol, 2010 Feb 04; 22(3). PMID: 20125015
Conceptualizing couples' decision making in PGD: emerging cognitive, emotional, and moral dimensions.
Patricia E Hershberger, Penny F Pierce.
Patient Educ Couns, 2010 Jan 12; 81(1). PMID: 20060677    Free PMC article.
Systematic Review.
Predictors of not pursuing infertility treatment after an infertility diagnosis: examination of a prospective U.S. cohort.
Michael L Eisenberg, James F Smith, +5 authors, Infertility Outcomes Program Project Group.
Fertil Steril, 2010 May 18; 94(6). PMID: 20471010    Free PMC article.
Development and pilot testing of a fertility decision aid for young women diagnosed with early breast cancer.
Michelle Peate, Bettina Meiser, +4 authors, Martha Hickey.
Breast J, 2010 Dec 07; 17(1). PMID: 21129095
Strategies for fertility preservation after chemotherapy: awareness among Irish cancer specialists.
I M Collins, L Fay, M J Kennedy.
Ir Med J, 2011 Mar 11; 104(1). PMID: 21391329
Determinants of access to fertility preservation in women with breast cancer.
Sanghoon Lee, Elke Heytens, +2 authors, Kutluk Oktay.
Fertil Steril, 2011 Mar 05; 95(6). PMID: 21371704    Free PMC article.
Tamoxifen for breast cancer chemoprevention: low uptake by high-risk women after evaluation of a breast lump.
Rebecca Taylor, Kenneth Taguchi.
Ann Fam Med, 2005 Jun 02; 3(3). PMID: 15928228    Free PMC article.
Risk of menopause during the first year after breast cancer diagnosis.
P J Goodwin, M Ennis, +2 authors, N Hood.
J Clin Oncol, 1999 Nov 24; 17(8). PMID: 10561298
The multi-dimensional measure of informed choice: a validation study.
Susan Michie, Elizabeth Dormandy, Theresa M Marteau.
Patient Educ Couns, 2002 Sep 11; 48(1). PMID: 12220754
Women's experiences with information provision and deciding about fertility preservation in the Netherlands: 'satisfaction in general, but unmet needs'.
Mirjam M Garvelink, Moniek M ter Kuile, +5 authors, Anne M Stiggelbout.
Health Expect, 2013 May 08; 18(5). PMID: 23647741    Free PMC article.
Contralateral prophylactic mastectomy in women with breast cancer: trends, predictors, and areas for future research.
Michaela S Tracy, Shoshana M Rosenberg, Laura Dominici, Ann H Partridge.
Breast Cancer Res Treat, 2013 Jul 31; 140(3). PMID: 23893127    Free PMC article.
Breast cancer survivorship issues.
Daniela Stan, Charles L Loprinzi, Kathryn J Ruddy.
Hematol Oncol Clin North Am, 2013 Aug 07; 27(4). PMID: 23915746    Free PMC article.
To preserve or not to preserve: how difficult is the decision about fertility preservation?
Jennifer E Mersereau, Linnea R Goodman, +3 authors, H Irene Su.
Cancer, 2013 Sep 17; 119(22). PMID: 24037854    Free PMC article.
Toward theoretical understanding of the fertility preservation decision-making process: examining information processing among young women with cancer.
Patricia E Hershberger, Lorna Finnegan, +2 authors, Jennifer Hirshfeld-Cytron.
Res Theory Nurs Pract, 2014 Feb 21; 27(4). PMID: 24552086    Free PMC article.
Prospective study of fertility concerns and preservation strategies in young women with breast cancer.
Kathryn J Ruddy, Shari I Gelber, +6 authors, Ann H Partridge.
J Clin Oncol, 2014 Feb 26; 32(11). PMID: 24567428    Free PMC article.
Highly Cited.
Desire for children, difficulties achieving a pregnancy, and infertility distress 3 to 7 years after cancer diagnosis.
Gabriela M Armuand, Lena Wettergren, Kenny A Rodriguez-Wallberg, Claudia Lampic.
Support Care Cancer, 2014 May 13; 22(10). PMID: 24817617    Free PMC article.
Estimates of young breast cancer survivors at risk for infertility in the U.S.
Katrina F Trivers, Aliza K Fink, +4 authors, Lori A Pollack.
Oncologist, 2014 Jun 22; 19(8). PMID: 24951610    Free PMC article.
Fertility and parenthood issues in young female cancer patients--a systematic review.
Aleksandra Sobota, Gozde Ozakinci.
J Cancer Surviv, 2014 Aug 12; 8(4). PMID: 25103606
Systematic Review.
Values clarification in a decision aid about fertility preservation: does it add to information provision?
Mirjam M Garvelink, Moniek M ter Kuile, Anne M Stiggelbout, Marieke de Vries.
BMC Med Inform Decis Mak, 2014 Aug 12; 14. PMID: 25106453    Free PMC article.
Preserving fertility in patients undergoing treatment for breast cancer: current perspectives.
Rebecca Moffat, Uwe Güth.
Breast Cancer (Dove Med Press), 2014 Aug 13; 6. PMID: 25114587    Free PMC article.
Does a decision aid for prostate cancer affect different aspects of decisional regret, assessed with new regret scales? A randomized, controlled trial.
Julia J van Tol-Geerdink, Jan Willem H Leer, +5 authors, Peep F M Stalmeier.
Health Expect, 2015 May 06; 19(2). PMID: 25940277    Free PMC article.
Sexual dysfunction and infertility as late effects of cancer treatment.
Leslie R Schover, Marleen van der Kaaij, +3 authors, Cecilie E Kiserud.
EJC Suppl, 2015 Jul 29; 12(1). PMID: 26217165    Free PMC article.
Factors associated with the receipt of fertility preservation services along the decision-making pathway in young Canadian female cancer patients.
Samantha Yee.
J Assist Reprod Genet, 2015 Nov 13; 33(2). PMID: 26560157    Free PMC article.
Young Adult Female Cancer Survivors' Decision Regret About Fertility Preservation.
Catherine Benedict, Bridgette Thom, Joanne F Kelvin.
J Adolesc Young Adult Oncol, 2015 Dec 24; 4(4). PMID: 26697271    Free PMC article.
Fertility preservation and cancer: challenges for adolescent and young adult patients.
Catherine Benedict, Bridgette Thom, Joanne F Kelvin.
Curr Opin Support Palliat Care, 2016 Jan 06; 10(1). PMID: 26730794    Free PMC article.
Fertility Preservation for the Young Breast Cancer Patient.
Shari B Goldfarb, Sabrina A Kamer, +6 authors, Mary L Gemignani.
Ann Surg Oncol, 2016 Jan 23; 23(5). PMID: 26790670    Free PMC article.
Young adult female cancer survivors' unmet information needs and reproductive concerns contribute to decisional conflict regarding posttreatment fertility preservation.
Catherine Benedict, Bridgette Thom, +4 authors, Joanne F Kelvin.
Cancer, 2016 May 24; 122(13). PMID: 27213483    Free PMC article.
Regret around fertility choices is decreased with pre-treatment counseling in gynecologic cancer patients.
Jessica L Chan, Joseph Letourneau, +4 authors, Mitchell P Rosen.
J Cancer Surviv, 2016 Aug 03; 11(1). PMID: 27480882    Free PMC article.
Psychological impact of fertility preservation techniques in women with gynaecological cancer.
Antonio Simone Laganà, Valentina Lucia La Rosa, +2 authors, Salvatore Giovanni Vitale.
Ecancermedicalscience, 2017 Mar 10; 11. PMID: 28275393    Free PMC article.
Assessing the usefulness and acceptability of a low health literacy online decision aid about reproductive choices for younger women with breast cancer: the aLLIAnCE pilot study protocol.
Michelle Peate, Sian Karen Smith, +8 authors, Martha Hickey.
Pilot Feasibility Stud, 2017 Jun 13; 3. PMID: 28603643    Free PMC article.
Psychosocial and behavioral impact of breast cancer risk assessed by testing for common risk variants: protocol of a prospective study.
Tatiane Yanes, Bettina Meiser, +6 authors, Paul James.
BMC Cancer, 2017 Jul 20; 17(1). PMID: 28720130    Free PMC article.
The Pathways fertility preservation decision aid website for women with cancer: development and field testing.
Terri L Woodard, Aubri S Hoffman, +7 authors, Robert J Volk.
J Cancer Surviv, 2017 Oct 17; 12(1). PMID: 29034438
Fertility preservation in post-pubescent female cancer patients: A practical guideline for clinicians.
Amirrtha Srikanthan, Eitan Amir, +8 authors, Abha Gupta.
Mol Clin Oncol, 2018 Feb 02; 8(1). PMID: 29387409    Free PMC article.
Pathways: patient-centred decision counselling for women at risk of cancer-related infertility: a protocol for a comparative effectiveness cluster randomised trial.
Terri Lynn Woodard, Aubri S Hoffman, +6 authors, Robert J Volk.
BMJ Open, 2018 Feb 23; 8(2). PMID: 29467138    Free PMC article.
Threat of biographical disruption: the gendered construction and experience of infertility following cancer for women and men.
Jane M Ussher, Janette Perz, Australian Cancer and Fertility Study Team (ACFST).
BMC Cancer, 2018 Mar 07; 18(1). PMID: 29506492    Free PMC article.
Uptake of Preimplantation Genetic Diagnosis in Female BRCA1 and BRCA2 Mutation Carriers.
Pnina Mor, Sarah Brennenstuhl, Kelly A Metcalfe.
J Genet Couns, 2018 Jun 03; 27(6). PMID: 29858758
The intersection of financial toxicity and family building in young adult cancer survivors.
Bridgette Thom, Catherine Benedict, Danielle N Friedman, Joanne F Kelvin.
Cancer, 2018 Jun 21; 124(16). PMID: 29924381    Free PMC article.
Oncofertility-An emerging discipline rather than a special consideration.
Antoinette Anazodo, Lauren Ataman-Millhouse, Yasmin Jayasinghe, Teresa K Woodruff.
Pediatr Blood Cancer, 2018 Jul 05; 65(11). PMID: 29972282    Free PMC article.
"Creating a family after battling cancer is exhausting and maddening": Exploring real-world experiences of young adult cancer survivors seeking financial assistance for family building after treatment.
Catherine Benedict, Jody-Ann McLeggon, +4 authors, Jennifer S Ford.
Psychooncology, 2018 Sep 22; 27(12). PMID: 30238545    Free PMC article.
Are publicly available internet resources enabling women to make informed fertility preservation decisions before starting cancer treatment: an environmental scan?
N Mahmoodi, H L Bekker, +3 authors, Cancer, Fertility and Me research team.
BMC Med Inform Decis Mak, 2018 Nov 21; 18(1). PMID: 30453942    Free PMC article.
Oncofertility: Meeting the Fertility Goals of Adolescents and Young Adults With Cancer.
H Irene Su, Yuton Tony Lee, Ronald Barr.
Cancer J, 2018 Nov 28; 24(6). PMID: 30480578    Free PMC article.
Family-building decision aid and planning tool for young adult women after cancer treatment: protocol for preliminary testing of a web-based decision support intervention in a single-arm pilot study.
Catherine Benedict, Jennifer S Ford, +3 authors, Michael Diefenbach.
BMJ Open, 2020 Jan 01; 9(12). PMID: 31888941    Free PMC article.
How can we improve oncofertility care for patients? A systematic scoping review of current international practice and models of care.
Antoinette Anazodo, Paula Laws, +29 authors, Elizabeth Sullivan.
Hum Reprod Update, 2018 Nov 22; 25(2). PMID: 30462263    Free PMC article.
Systematic Review.
Protocol for the development and acceptability of a fertility-related decision aid for young women with breast cancer in Portugal.
Vânia Gonçalves, Luzia Travado, Pedro Lopes Ferreira, Gwendolyn Quinn.
BMJ Open, 2019 Jul 28; 9(7). PMID: 31345986    Free PMC article.
Perceptions of participating in family-centered fertility research among adolescent and young adult males newly diagnosed with cancer: A qualitative study.
Leena Nahata, Taylor L Morgan, +7 authors, Cynthia A Gerhardt.
Pediatr Blood Cancer, 2019 Aug 14; 66(11). PMID: 31407498    Free PMC article.
Does a web-based decision aid improve informed choice for fertility preservation in women with breast cancer (DECISIF)? Study protocol for a randomised controlled trial.
Alexandra Benoit, Michael Grynberg, +3 authors, Grégoire Moutel.
BMJ Open, 2020 Feb 13; 10(2). PMID: 32047010    Free PMC article.
Exploring the facilitators and barriers to using an online infertility risk prediction tool (FoRECAsT) for young women with breast cancer: a qualitative study protocol.
Zobaida Edib, Yasmin Jayasinghe, +15 authors, Michelle Peate.
BMJ Open, 2020 Feb 13; 10(2). PMID: 32047016    Free PMC article.
Fertility preservation in breast cancer with case-based examples for guidance.
Mary E Hampe, Alice S Rhoton-Vlasak.
J Assist Reprod Genet, 2020 Feb 03; 37(3). PMID: 32008180    Free PMC article.
Fertility preservation in women affected by gynaecological cancer: the importance of an integrated gynaecological and psychological approach.
Valentina Lucia La Rosa, Simone Garzon, +5 authors, Antonio Schiattarella.
Ecancermedicalscience, 2020 May 19; 14. PMID: 32419847    Free PMC article.
Satisfaction, disappointment and regret surrounding fertility preservation decisions in the paediatric and adolescent cancer population.
Sadunee Jayasuriya, Michelle Peate, +10 authors, Yasmin Jayasinghe.
J Assist Reprod Genet, 2019 Aug 11; 36(9). PMID: 31399917    Free PMC article.
Fertility Preservation in Children and Adolescents With Cancer: Pilot of a Decision Aid for Parents of Children and Adolescents With Cancer.
Catherine Allingham, Lynn Gillam, +7 authors, Yasmin Jayasinghe.
JMIR Pediatr Parent, 2019 Sep 14; 1(2). PMID: 31518288    Free PMC article.
Integration of partners of young women with cancer in oncofertility evidence-based informational resources.
Vânia Gonçalves, Pedro L Ferreira, Gwendolyn P Quinn.
Cancer Med, 2020 Aug 31; 9(20). PMID: 32864852    Free PMC article.
How online ADHD-related information affects Chinese parents' decisions?
Xiao-He Yu, Le Zhong, Jia Huang.
World J Pediatr, 2018 Nov 28; 15(1). PMID: 30478599    Free PMC article.
Impact of a novel family-centered values clarification tool on adolescent sperm banking attempts at the time of a new cancer diagnosis.
Leena Nahata, Taylor M Dattilo, +10 authors, Cynthia A Gerhardt.
J Assist Reprod Genet, 2021 Feb 11;. PMID: 33564937
Development and testing of a tailored online fertility preservation decision aid for female cancer patients.
Michelle van den Berg, Elleke van der Meij, +10 authors, Rosella P M G Hermens.
Cancer Med, 2021 Feb 14; 10(5). PMID: 33580749    Free PMC article.