. 2016 Aug; 64:65-72.
doi: 10.1016/j.semcdb.2016.08.025.

Molecular heterogeneity in breast cancer: State of the science and implications for patient care

Rachel E Ellsworth 1 Heather L Blackburn 2 Craig D Shriver 3 Patrick Soon-Shiong 4 Darrell L Ellsworth 5 
  • PMID: 27569190
  •     63 citations


The identification of extensive genetic heterogeneity in human breast carcinomas poses a significant challenge for designing effective treatment regimens. Significant genomic evolution often occurs during breast cancer progression, creating variability within primary tumors as well as between the primary carcinoma and metastases. Current risk allocations and treatment recommendations for breast cancer patients are based largely on characteristics of the primary tumor; however, genetic differences between disseminated tumor cells and the primary carcinoma may negatively impact treatment efficacy and survival. In this review we (1) present current information about genomic variability within primary breast carcinomas, between primary tumors and regional/distant metastases, among circulating tumor cells (CTCs) and disseminated tumor cells (DTCs), and in cell-free nucleic acids in circulation, and (2) describe how this heterogeneity affects clinical care and outcomes such as recurrence and therapeutic resistance. Understanding the evolution and functional significance of the composite breast cancer genome within each patient is critical for developing effective therapies that can overcome obstacles presented by molecular heterogeneity.

Keywords: Breast cancer; Cell-free DNA; Circulating tumor cells; Intratumor heterogeneity; Metastasis.

Circulating Cell-Free DNA in Dogs with Mammary Tumors: Short and Long Fragments and Integrity Index.
Giorgia Beffagna, Alessandro Sammarco, +12 authors, Valentina Zappulli.
PLoS One, 2017 Jan 13; 12(1). PMID: 28081183    Free PMC article.
Cell adhesion heterogeneity reinforces tumour cell dissemination: novel insights from a mathematical model.
David Reher, Barbara Klink, Andreas Deutsch, Anja Voss-Böhme.
Biol Direct, 2017 Aug 13; 12(1). PMID: 28800767    Free PMC article.
Circulating microRNAs in breast cancer: novel diagnostic and prognostic biomarkers.
Rimi Hamam, Dana Hamam, +5 authors, Nehad M Alajez.
Cell Death Dis, 2017 Sep 08; 8(9). PMID: 28880270    Free PMC article.
Highly Cited. Review.
The biology and mathematical modelling of glioma invasion: a review.
J C L Alfonso, K Talkenberger, +5 authors, A Deutsch.
J R Soc Interface, 2017 Nov 10; 14(136). PMID: 29118112    Free PMC article.
Tumor Heterogeneity in Breast Cancer.
Gulisa Turashvili, Edi Brogi.
Front Med (Lausanne), 2017 Dec 26; 4. PMID: 29276709    Free PMC article.
Highly Cited. Review.
Pathological Bases and Clinical Impact of Intratumor Heterogeneity in Clear Cell Renal Cell Carcinoma.
José I López, Javier C Angulo.
Curr Urol Rep, 2018 Jan 29; 19(1). PMID: 29374850
Kallikrein-related peptidase 6 (KLK6) expression differentiates tumor subtypes and predicts clinical outcome in breast cancer patients.
Christoforos Haritos, Kleita Michaelidou, +4 authors, Andreas Scorilas.
Clin Exp Med, 2018 Feb 13; 18(2). PMID: 29435805
A Bayesian approach to determine the composition of heterogeneous cancer tissue.
Ashish Katiyar, Anwoy Mohanty, +4 authors, Michael L Bittner.
BMC Bioinformatics, 2018 Mar 29; 19(Suppl 3). PMID: 29589556    Free PMC article.
Overview on Clinical Relevance of Intra-Tumor Heterogeneity.
Giorgio Stanta, Serena Bonin.
Front Med (Lausanne), 2018 Apr 24; 5. PMID: 29682505    Free PMC article.
Highly Cited. Review.
The Heterogeneity of Lipid Metabolism in Cancer.
Joshua K Park, Nathan J Coffey, Aaron Limoges, Anne Le.
Adv Exp Med Biol, 2018 Jun 28; 1063. PMID: 29946774
Personalizing Radiation Treatment Delivery in the Management of Breast Cancer.
Kamran A Ahmed, G Daniel Grass, +7 authors, Roberto Diaz.
Int J Breast Cancer, 2018 Jul 10; 2018. PMID: 29984003    Free PMC article.
Generation of Immortalised But Unstable Cells after hTERT Introduction in Telomere-Compromised and p53-Deficient vHMECs.
Aina Bernal, Elisenda Zafon, +2 authors, Laura Tusell.
Int J Mol Sci, 2018 Jul 19; 19(7). PMID: 30018248    Free PMC article.
A SIRT1-centered circuitry regulates breast cancer stemness and metastasis.
Lei Shi, Xiaolong Tang, +8 authors, Baohua Liu.
Oncogene, 2018 Jul 25; 37(49). PMID: 30038266    Free PMC article.
Prosopis juliflora (Sw.), DC induces apoptosis and cell cycle arrest in triple negative breast cancer cells: in vitro and in vivo investigations.
Bhimashankar Gurushidhappa Utage, Milind Shivajirao Patole, +2 authors, Rajesh Nivarti Gacche.
Oncotarget, 2018 Aug 14; 9(54). PMID: 30100991    Free PMC article.
Breast cancer development and progression: Risk factors, cancer stem cells, signaling pathways, genomics, and molecular pathogenesis.
Yixiao Feng, Mia Spezia, +15 authors, Guosheng Ren.
Genes Dis, 2018 Sep 28; 5(2). PMID: 30258937    Free PMC article.
Highly Cited. Review.
Tumor-derived granulocyte colony-stimulating factor diminishes efficacy of breast tumor cell vaccines.
Sruthi Ravindranathan, Khue G Nguyen, +5 authors, David A Zaharoff.
Breast Cancer Res, 2018 Oct 24; 20(1). PMID: 30348199    Free PMC article.
Synchronous bilateral breast cancer: A case report of heterogeneous estrogen receptor status.
Sunny Dhadlie, Joseph Whitfield, Rasika Hendahewa.
Int J Surg Case Rep, 2018 Nov 06; 53. PMID: 30391732    Free PMC article.
Expression of Alpha-Enolase (ENO1), Myc Promoter-Binding Protein-1 (MBP-1) and Matrix Metalloproteinases (MMP-2 and MMP-9) Reflect the Nature and Aggressiveness of Breast Tumors.
Patrizia Cancemi, Miriam Buttacavoli, Elena Roz, Salvatore Feo.
Int J Mol Sci, 2019 Aug 17; 20(16). PMID: 31416219    Free PMC article.
CTCs 2020: Great Expectations or Unreasonable Dreams.
Elisabetta Rossi, Francesco Fabbri.
Cells, 2019 Aug 30; 8(9). PMID: 31461978    Free PMC article.
Identification of new cancer stem cell markers and signaling pathways in HER‑2‑positive breast cancer by transcriptome sequencing.
Lu Feng, Shangke Huang, +3 authors, Xinhan Zhao.
Int J Oncol, 2019 Sep 24; 55(5). PMID: 31545416    Free PMC article.
Concurrent targeting of BMI1 and CDK4/6 abrogates tumor growth in vitro and in vivo.
Ramesh Elango, Radhakrishnan Vishnubalaji, +6 authors, Nehad M Alajez.
Sci Rep, 2019 Sep 25; 9(1). PMID: 31548560    Free PMC article.
Molecular harvesting with electroporation for tissue profiling.
Alexander Golberg, Julia Sheviryov, +2 authors, Zohar Yakhini.
Sci Rep, 2019 Nov 02; 9(1). PMID: 31673038    Free PMC article.
Establishment and Characterization of a CTC Cell Line from Peripheral Blood of Breast Cancer Patient.
Pan Zhao, Wenbin Zhou, +12 authors, Chang Zou.
J Cancer, 2019 Nov 26; 10(24). PMID: 31762819    Free PMC article.
Topoisomerase I activity and sensitivity to camptothecin in breast cancer-derived cells: a comparative study.
Cinzia Tesauro, Anne Katrine Simonsen, +10 authors, Irina Gromova.
BMC Cancer, 2019 Dec 01; 19(1). PMID: 31783818    Free PMC article.
Dichotomic effects of clinically used drugs on tumor growth, bone remodeling and pain management.
David André Barrière, Élora Midavaine, +8 authors, Philippe Sarret.
Sci Rep, 2019 Dec 29; 9(1). PMID: 31882872    Free PMC article.
Identification and transfer of spatial transcriptomics signatures for cancer diagnosis.
Niyaz Yoosuf, José Fernández Navarro, +2 authors, Carsten O Daub.
Breast Cancer Res, 2020 Jan 15; 22(1). PMID: 31931856    Free PMC article.
The transcriptional landscape of lncRNAs reveals the oncogenic function of LINC00511 in ER-negative breast cancer.
Jian Zhang, Shiyao Sui, +4 authors, Da Pang.
Cell Death Dis, 2019 Aug 10; 10(8). PMID: 31395854    Free PMC article.
A framework for transcriptome-wide association studies in breast cancer in diverse study populations.
Arjun Bhattacharya, Montserrat García-Closas, +3 authors, Michael I Love.
Genome Biol, 2020 Feb 23; 21(1). PMID: 32079541    Free PMC article.
Acid specific dark quencher QC1 pHLIP for multi-spectral optoacoustic diagnoses of breast cancer.
Sheryl Roberts, Arianna Strome, +10 authors, Thomas Reiner.
Sci Rep, 2019 Jun 14; 9(1). PMID: 31189972    Free PMC article.
Mutation Profiling of Key Cancer Genes in Primary Breast Cancers and Their Distant Metastases.
Willemijne A M E Schrijver, Pier Selenica, +8 authors, Cathy B Moelans.
Cancer Res, 2018 Apr 05; 78(12). PMID: 29615433    Free PMC article.
The Impact of Tumor Eco-Evolution in Renal Cell Carcinoma Sampling.
Estíbaliz López-Fernández, José I López.
Cancers (Basel), 2018 Dec 07; 10(12). PMID: 30518081    Free PMC article.
An isomiR expression panel based novel breast cancer classification approach using improved mutual information.
Chaowang Lan, Hui Peng, +2 authors, Jinyan Li.
BMC Med Genomics, 2019 Jan 02; 11(Suppl 6). PMID: 30598116    Free PMC article.
A Critical Insight into the Clinical Translation of PD-1/PD-L1 Blockade Therapy in Clear Cell Renal Cell Carcinoma.
Caroline E Nunes-Xavier, Javier C Angulo, Rafael Pulido, José I López.
Curr Urol Rep, 2019 Jan 16; 20(1). PMID: 30645700
α-Parvin promotes breast cancer progression and metastasis through interaction with G3BP2 and regulation of TWIST1 signaling.
Ying Sun, Yanyan Ding, +9 authors, Chuanyue Wu.
Oncogene, 2019 Feb 26; 38(24). PMID: 30804457
Investigating circulating tumor cells and distant metastases in patient-derived orthotopic xenograft models of triple-negative breast cancer.
Vishnu C Ramani, Clementine A Lemaire, +10 authors, Stefanie S Jeffrey.
Breast Cancer Res, 2019 Aug 30; 21(1). PMID: 31462307    Free PMC article.
Thymoquinone Enhances Paclitaxel Anti-Breast Cancer Activity via Inhibiting Tumor-Associated Stem Cells Despite Apparent Mathematical Antagonism.
Hanan A Bashmail, Aliaa A Alamoudi, +3 authors, Ahmed M Al-Abd.
Molecules, 2020 Jan 24; 25(2). PMID: 31968657    Free PMC article.
Prognostic Significance of Somatostatin Receptor Heterogeneity in Progressive Neuroendocrine Tumor Treated with Lu-177 DOTATOC or Lu-177 DOTATATE.
Josephine Graf, Ulrich-Frank Pape, +5 authors, Vikas Prasad.
Eur J Nucl Med Mol Imaging, 2019 Aug 16; 47(4). PMID: 31414209
miRNAs as Biomarkers in Disease: Latest Findings Regarding Their Role in Diagnosis and Prognosis.
Carmen Elena Condrat, Dana Claudia Thompson, +6 authors, Silviu Cristian Voinea.
Cells, 2020 Jan 26; 9(2). PMID: 31979244    Free PMC article.
18F-FDG PET/CT radiomic predictors of pathologic complete response (pCR) to neoadjuvant chemotherapy in breast cancer patients.
Panli Li, Xiuying Wang, +7 authors, Gang Huang.
Eur J Nucl Med Mol Imaging, 2020 Jan 27; 47(5). PMID: 31982990
Emergence of Circulating MicroRNAs in Breast Cancer as Diagnostic and Therapeutic Efficacy Biomarkers.
Vaishali Aggarwal, Kumari Priyanka, Hardeep Singh Tuli.
Mol Diagn Ther, 2020 Feb 19; 24(2). PMID: 32067191
17‑AAG synergizes with Belinostat to exhibit a negative effect on the proliferation and invasion of MDA‑MB‑231 breast cancer cells.
Yu Zuo, Heng Xu, +6 authors, Hao Zhang.
Oncol Rep, 2020 Apr 03; 43(6). PMID: 32236631    Free PMC article.
Tumor Heterogeneity Correlates with Less Immune Response and Worse Survival in Breast Cancer Patients.
Kerry-Ann McDonald, Tsutomu Kawaguchi, +8 authors, Kazuaki Takabe.
Ann Surg Oncol, 2019 Apr 10; 26(7). PMID: 30963401    Free PMC article.
Highly Cited.
PRRX1 isoform PRRX1A regulates the stemness phenotype and epithelial-mesenchymal transition (EMT) of cancer stem-like cells (CSCs) derived from non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC).
Lei Sun, Tao Han, +5 authors, Wenya Li.
Transl Lung Cancer Res, 2020 Jul 18; 9(3). PMID: 32676335    Free PMC article.
Homologous repair deficiency score for identifying breast cancers with defective DNA damage response.
Ahrum Min, Kwangsoo Kim, +6 authors, Seock-Ah Im.
Sci Rep, 2020 Jul 29; 10(1). PMID: 32719318    Free PMC article.
Molecular analysis of circulating tumor DNA from breast cancer patients before and after surgery and following adjuvant chemotherapy.
Katarina Zelinova, Marianna Jagelkova, +4 authors, Karol Dokus.
Mol Clin Oncol, 2020 Aug 09; 13(4). PMID: 32765873    Free PMC article.
High mutation burden of circulating cell-free DNA in early-stage breast cancer patients is associated with a poor relapse-free survival.
Jouni Kujala, Jaana M Hartikainen, +3 authors, Arto Mannermaa.
Cancer Med, 2020 Jul 01; 9(16). PMID: 32602248    Free PMC article.
Microvesicles in Cancer: Small Size, Large Potential.
Kerstin Menck, Suganja Sivaloganathan, Annalen Bleckmann, Claudia Binder.
Int J Mol Sci, 2020 Aug 01; 21(15). PMID: 32731639    Free PMC article.
Genomic comparison of paired primary breast carcinomas and lymph node macrometastases using the Oncotype DX Breast Recurrence Score® test.
Susan K Boolbol, Manju Harshan, +8 authors, Stephen Malamud.
Breast Cancer Res Treat, 2019 Jul 16; 177(3). PMID: 31302854    Free PMC article.
Characterization of cancer genomic heterogeneity by next-generation sequencing advances precision medicine in cancer treatment.
Jialing Zhang, Stephan Stanislaw Späth, +2 authors, Xinghua Pan.
Precis Clin Med, 2019 Jan 29; 1(1). PMID: 30687561    Free PMC article.
Highly Cited. Review.
PTEN as a Prognostic/Predictive Biomarker in Cancer: An Unfulfilled Promise?
Chiara Bazzichetto, Fabiana Conciatori, +5 authors, Ludovica Ciuffreda.
Cancers (Basel), 2019 Mar 31; 11(4). PMID: 30925702    Free PMC article.
Highly Cited. Review.
Heterogeneity of targeted lung lesion predicts platinum-based first-line therapy outcomes and overall survival for metastatic triple-negative breast cancer patients with lung metastasis: a "PET biopsy" method.
Yizhao Xie, Bingxin Gu, +8 authors, Biyun Wang.
Cancer Manag Res, 2019 Jul 17; 11. PMID: 31308743    Free PMC article.
Inhibition of JNK-Mediated Autophagy Promotes Proscillaridin A- Induced Apoptosis via ROS Generation, Intracellular Ca+2 Oscillation and Inhibiting STAT3 Signaling in Breast Cancer Cells.
Muhammad Zubair Saleem, Mohammed Alshwmi, +7 authors, Tonghui Ma.
Front Pharmacol, 2020 Oct 06; 11. PMID: 33013353    Free PMC article.
Molecular phenotype discordance between primary and synchronous metastatic lesions of breast cancer and its determinant role in guiding treatment decisions: a case report.
Jing-Hao Yao, Wu-Qiong Zhang, +4 authors, Yan Yang.
Am J Transl Res, 2020 Oct 13; 12(9). PMID: 33042465    Free PMC article.
Breast Cancer Cells in Microgravity: New Aspects for Cancer Research.
Mohamed Zakaria Nassef, Daniela Melnik, +7 authors, Marcus Krüger.
Int J Mol Sci, 2020 Oct 09; 21(19). PMID: 33027908    Free PMC article.
Shortwave infrared emitting multicolored nanoprobes for biomarker-specific cancer imaging in vivo.
Harini Kantamneni, Shravani Barkund, +9 authors, Prabhas V Moghe.
BMC Cancer, 2020 Nov 12; 20(1). PMID: 33172421    Free PMC article.
Intratumoral heterogeneity of second-harmonic generation scattering from tumor collagen and its effects on metastatic risk prediction.
Danielle E Desa, Robert L Strawderman, +5 authors, Edward B Brown.
BMC Cancer, 2020 Dec 12; 20(1). PMID: 33302909    Free PMC article.
Circulating tumor DNA-based predictive biomarkers in breast cancer clinical trials: a narrative review.
Oraianthi Fiste, Michael Liontos, +3 authors, Flora Zagouri.
Ann Transl Med, 2021 Jan 14; 8(23). PMID: 33437802    Free PMC article.
NGS-guided precision oncology in metastatic breast and gynecological cancer: first experiences at the CCC Munich LMU.
Elena Sultova, C Benedikt Westphalen, +13 authors, Rachel Wuerstlein.
Arch Gynecol Obstet, 2020 Dec 06; 303(5). PMID: 33277683    Free PMC article.
Breast cancer patient-derived scaffolds as a tool to monitor chemotherapy responses in human tumor microenvironments.
Maria Carmen Leiva, Elena Garre, +5 authors, Göran Landberg.
J Cell Physiol, 2020 Dec 29; 236(6). PMID: 33368325    Free PMC article.
Precision oncology for breast cancer through clinical trials.
Aurora S Blucher, Gordon B Mills, Yiu Huen Tsang.
Clin Exp Metastasis, 2021 May 06;. PMID: 33950412
DeCompress: tissue compartment deconvolution of targeted mRNA expression panels using compressed sensing.
Arjun Bhattacharya, Alina M Hamilton, Melissa A Troester, Michael I Love.
Nucleic Acids Res, 2021 Feb 02; 49(8). PMID: 33524140    Free PMC article.
Genetic landscape of breast cancer and mutation tracking with circulating tumor DNA in Chinese women.
Yinghao Wang, Lizhi Lin, +19 authors, Ouchen Wang.
Aging (Albany NY), 2021 Apr 25; 13(8). PMID: 33893247    Free PMC article.
Using dynamic cell communication improves treatment strategies of breast cancer.
Zhibo Liu, Song Hu, +3 authors, Daya Luo.
Cancer Cell Int, 2021 May 27; 21(1). PMID: 34034721    Free PMC article.